EU edges out U.S. in getting India to slash auto tariffs, but can European carmakers win big?

This report is from this week’s CNBC’s “Inside India” newsletter which brings you timely, insightful news and market commentary on the emerging powerhouse. Subscribe here.

New Delhi-based tech startup founder Ashita Gupta loves her cars. With prospects of luxury European cars becoming cheaper, Gupta, who drives an Audi A6, is considering buying another high-end vehicle.

It “doesn’t make sense” to spend so much money on a second car, but if an Audi R8 or Audi RS4 were to become “affordable” it would be worth purchasing, she says.

On Tuesday, India and the European Union announced the “mother of all deals,” that includes New Delhi slashing import duty on European cars gradually to 10% from 70%-110% at present. This would apply to a quota of 250,000 vehicles per year, and on cars priced above 15,000 euros ($17,952)

India has long shielded its auto market, the world’s third largest, by using prohibitive levels of tariffs on imports to safeguard domestic auto companies, while pushing global firms to build local manufacturing plants. U.S. President Donald Trump, in fact, has often criticized India for protecting its local auto industry from imports and has demanded lower tariffs on American car companies, calling them “very unfair.” Now, Brussels has edged out Washington in getting New Delhi to drop its hard stance on auto tariffs, securing a lucrative deal for European auto majors.

Diwaker Murugan, auto analyst at Omdia, told CNBC that EU brands now have a premium pass to the world’s third largest car market, while US companies are currently facing a huge levy. Omdia estimates India’s car market to touch 6 million by 2030, fueled by a young population with higher disposable incomes. However, nearly 95% of cars sold in financial year 2025 were priced below 2 million rupees ($21,756), according to data from S&P Global-owned Indian research and ratings agency Crisil. Even with the lowered tariffs the price of imported European cars will exceed this range as local taxes get added to the final price, according to auto experts, so the total addressable market for European car companies will still be limited.

India’s mass car market is dominated by Maruti Suzuki and Hyundai, which have been manufacturing in India for more than two decades, and local players Tata and Mahindra whose high‑volume models fall under 2.5 million rupees. The European Automobile Manufacturers’ Association said in a statement that the India-EU deal will greatly help European automobile exports enter a market of 4 million passenger cars that, until now, has been protected by prohibitively high import tariffs, while pointing to curbs such as quota limitations and residual tariffs that will limit the potential benefit to some extent.

The top five European luxury brands, Mercedes-Benz, BMW, JLR, Audi and Volvo, sold 49,000 cars in India in financial year ended March 2025 compared with total passenger car sales of 4.3 million, according to data from Crisil. Puneet Gupta, director of technical research at S&P Global Mobility, said European car companies dominate the luxury segment, but overall, their position is increasingly under pressure with a shrinking market share. He explains that Indian and Korean manufacturers have aggressively scaled up their presence through capacity expansion, frequent product launches, and rapid network growth while the Europeans have been relatively cautious on investments in the last few years.

The free trade agreement, which is likely to come into force later this year, could make Europeans companies reassess their India business plans as trade barriers ease. Hardeep Singh Brar, president and CEO, BMW Group India echoes this sentiment, telling CNBC in an email exchange that the FTA could create opportunities to introduce new and niche products and, if demand scales, support deeper localization over time. The Indian arm of German carmaker BMW Group locally manufactures over 95% of its cars and yet it sold a little over 18,000 units in 2025, which was its highest so far.

This FTA potential, coupled with evolving consumer preferences, has caused some worry among Indian auto investors, as the move to slash tariffs so dramatically exposes market leaders to increased competition in high margin segments. Murugan noted that the true battleground is the Premium SUV segment which is priced above 2.3 million rupees. By allowing European brands to land vehicles at competitive prices in this bracket, the agreement might create a confrontation between European badge-value and Indian flagship SUVs. Some high-end variants of locally manufactured cars like Mahindra’ Scorpio or Tata Safari are priced close to 2.5 million rupee and are popular with customers.

After the deal was announced on Tuesday, shares of leading India auto companies including Mahindra & Mahindra, Hyundai Motor India, Maruti Suzuki and Tata Motors ended down between 1.5% and 4%. According to Citi, local manufacturers will see competition as the gap between high-end models from Indian OEMs and entry level models of EU OEMs currently being imported narrows. But industry leaders and trade bodies in India have welcomed the trade deal, as it still protects the majority of sales volumes.

Anish Shah, group chief executive and managing director of Mahindra Group, said the deal is a huge positive for the auto sector as it will give Indian carmakers duty free access to markets in Europe and attract European auto companies to invest in India. While most experts agree that even with the lowered trade barriers, European car companies are unlikely to dent the dominance of local auto manufacturers in the near term, competition is set to intensify as customer preferences evolve. Gupta says she wants to see cars with better amenities come to India, and hopes that following the trade deal, European car companies would launch their latest models in India so that customers can have latest amenities at reasonable prices.